Skills vs Stuff

Homesteading & Country Living Forum

Help Support Homesteading & Country Living Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Sentry18

Thrivalist
Neighbor
HCL Supporter
Joined
Nov 26, 2017
Messages
19,105
Location
US of A
https://beansbulletsbandagesandyou.com/bullets/2020/02/17/skills-vs-stuff/

Skills vs Stuff
Posted on February 17, 2020 by Jim Cobb
Spend more than about 8 seconds in any survival related forum and you’ll hear some variation on this phrase – Skills are better than Stuff.

Skills vs Stuff
The basic premise at work here is that learning skills is a more valuable investment than buying stuff, for several reasons:

–Skills don’t rot or fall apart (though they are perishable and will decline without practice)
–Skills don’t take up storage space at home
–Skills add no weight to the pack

All of that is absolutely correct and if you had to choose between learning a practical skill or buying a new toy, I mean gun-to-your-head can choose only one, then go with the skill every time.

But, in the grand scheme of things, today, right now, at this moment, you have the freedom to choose both. There is no reason you can’t acquire stuff while at the same time learning new skills. It isn’t an either/or proposition.

The human race invented tools for a reason. Simply put, they make tasks easier to accomplish. We could hunt around for the appropriate materials to construct a bow drill, then grind out an ember for our fire. Or, we can pull a Bic from our pocket. When true survival is on the line and hypothermia is setting in, being able to a get a fire going quickly could mean life or death.

We could search for birch bark and make a container in which we can boil water to disinfect it for drinking. Or, we can carry a small water filter. Or a steel water bottle if we insist on boiling the water.

Don’t get me wrong
I am NOT suggesting there is no value in learning primitive skills. Far from it. That knowledge is tremendously powerful and I encourage all to seek out classes with true professionals who have earned great reputations. If you lose everything, you will have those skills to use.

That said, you might be setting yourself up for failure if you enter into the prepper/survival world with a mindset of eschewing “stuff” because skills are better. Yes, skills are damn important but investing in some “stuff” will make your life easier and will probably increase your chances of making it through a true survival situation.

2017-04-02-15.49.54.jpg

Here I am setting up the drip irrigation line to run from the roof rain barrel to a garden bed. One can easily just run the drip line in a loop around the base of a tree.

Learn how to make and use a bow drill and other primitive means of starting a fire. But, still pack a disposable lighter, ferro rod, and other modern implements.

Learn when and how to use signal fires. But, still pack a good whistle, signal mirror, and an extra battery pack for your phone.

Learn how to use snares, deadfalls, and other traps for acquiring food. But, still pack a few granola bars, snacks, and such.

Above all else, please make it a habit to tell another person any time you’re going to hit the trail. Let them know where you’re going, when you’ll get there, and when to expect you to return. If they don’t hear from you, they should notify the authorities so they can come look for your lost butt.
 
Good article. Strikes a good balance between skills and stuff. One other take I have heard is to focus your "stuff" on the things that are the hardest to replicate in nature.
 
IMHO, I think the author is correct in that both are necessary. Skills are great, but many skills have limited scope without stuff. I'm glad I have my nursing skills, but without stuff to support my skills, there's only so much I (or a doctor) can do. Treatment and diagnosis for many ills will not be possible without stuff like medicine, dressings, IV fluids, x-rays, ventilator, etc. etc.

Without skills or stuff.....you better be ready to endure some discomfort, at the very least. Those folks in the horse and buggy days were tough, but died much earlier in life than what we have today. The more adaptable you are to life's surprises, the better off you will be.
 
IMHO, I think the author is correct in that both are necessary. Skills are great, but many skills have limited scope without stuff. I'm glad I have my nursing skills, but without stuff to support my skills, there's only so much I (or a doctor) can do. Treatment and diagnosis for many ills will not be possible without stuff like medicine, dressings, IV fluids, x-rays, ventilator, etc. etc.

Without skills or stuff.....you better be ready to endure some discomfort, at the very least. Those folks in the horse and buggy days were tough, but died much earlier in life than what we have today. The more adaptable you are to life's surprises, the better off you will be.
I think of lack of skills when people want to stock MRE's. They are not used to cooking, or maybe lack cooking skills. But it also could be a thought to reduce the need to have a stove or cooking time.
 
A mechanic, an electrician, a doctor, a woodworker are just people without their tools and supplies.
I need to cut wood to make it into something. I need tools to rebuild a motor. I need wire to build a circuit.
I can make a stone axe or hammer but you won't repair that engine or build fine furniture without good tools.
 
Pants and shirt, you kind of want both. As you know I found myself in a survival situation this winter. My skills told me not only how to survive but what items to have in my survival kit and how to use them. Stuff doesn't help if you don't know how to use it or if it's left somewhere else. I didn't use everything in my emergency kit but I knew what items were needed for that situation.
 
Skills are very important.. but without 2 kinds of stuff , food and bullets ,there will not be a lot of opportunity to leverage skills, except as someones slave.
 
Most everyone on this site have both. Everyone here also has the long-distance help of the rest.

I have actually had people (friends) from forums come to my aid without asking , to help me thru a situation.

I would do the same if able.

Remember Gumpy?

Btw, a little of both will be necessary to survive true shtf.

Jim
 

Latest posts

Back
Top