That system would probably work, but it has a bunch of electronics in it. that would be hard to trouble shoot in a pinch, the system you have now can be manually overridden
First step is to check your connections at the switch. can you post a picture of the switch showing the wiring and the point blocks. Do you own a volt meter?
First step is to check your connections at the switch. can you post a picture of the switch showing the wiring and the point blocks. Do you own a volt meter?